Altered Images

From the early 1900s to the 1980s – the days before Adobe Photoshop – photographers and editors had to manually alter photographs for publication in the newspaper.

Photographs were often retouched with paint or airbrushed. Transparencies, cut outs, and photo collages were also employed. For the most part, retouching emphasized aspects of the photo that would enhance the reader’s appreciation of the image. Other times they were altered and transformed (often in humorous ways) to illustrate a story.

The Toronto Star’s code of ethics now requires altered photos to be clearly labelled as Photo Illustrations so that they are not confused with documentary photographs.

The painted arrows on this photo illustrate the robbers’ dramatic get-away from the bank after escaping with $12,549. The hold-up men ran from the Bank of Montreal branch on Royce Avenue in Toronto and jumped into their waiting car. The car careened around the corner, leaped the curb to nick a pole, and sped north on Symington Ave.

Queen’s Hotel on Front Street, Toronto

Queen’s Hotel on Front Street, Toronto
Unknown Photographer
1927 original photo; December 1929 composite

The Queen’s hotel, on the site of the present-day Royal York Hotel, is illustrated with a diagram of a planned tunnel to connect the building to Union Station.

This photo was originally published on February 11, 1947, unaltered, with an army vehicle throwing flames. On November 7, 1959, the truck was substituted for the army vehicle in order to illustrate bootleggers using flamethrowers “to foil police.”

Dalton Camp

Dalton Camp
Reg Innell / Toronto Star
July 1969

A Toronto Star editor ordered the art department to “Fix side burns” on this photo of Dalton Camp, Canadian journalist and Progressive Conservative party strategist.

The altered sideburn image was used in the newspaper on July 26, 1969 as a small head shot.

Author Marion Engel

Author Marion Engel
Reg Innell / Toronto Star
April 7, 1976

The art department eliminated Engel's hand and reconstructed her sweater using paint and airbrushing techniques in order to create a head shot for publication purposes.

University of Toronto students protest celebration of Lenin’s birth

University of Toronto students protest celebration of Lenin’s birth
Boris Spremo, C.M. / Toronto Star
April 3, 1970

The original photo on the left was altered to remove the word “Bullshit” from the placard.

Note the image at the right showing the alteration in the newspaper on April 4, 1970. 

Dwight D. Eisenhower and his wife Mamie

Dwight D. Eisenhower and his wife Mamie
Norman James (1907-1992)
1946

When Eisenhower and his wife visited Toronto’s Hart House in 1946, the Toronto Star cut two photographs, one of Ike and the other of Mamie, to produce a single composite image for publication in the paper.